Log in

No account? Create an account

The Quiet Game

When I announced my intention to do The Southern Lit challenge again this year, a blogging friend suggested that the Penn Cage books by Greg Iles, which are set in Mississippi, might fit the bill. The first book is entitled The Quiet Game and luckily I was able to reserve a copy from the library.


Famous writer and prosecuting attorney, Penn Cage, has recently been widowed. He has a young, four year old daughter who is traumatised by the loss and he decides to take her home to his parents' house, where he grew up, to heal. His home town is Natchez, an antebellum city, in the state of Mississippi. On the plane he meets Caitlin Masters, unbeknown to him, a journalist working for a newspaper in the same town. The lives of these two are to become inextricably entwined.

Arriving home, Penn senses that something is not right with his parents. Reluctantly, his father, a doctor, eventually tells him that he's being blackmailed by Ray Presley, a killer and ex-policeman with a finger in many crooked deals. Penn sets out to put a stop to this, only to discover connections to a case some years ago when the local big-wig, Leo Marston, tried to send his father to prison for malpractise. Penn had been dating Leo's daughter, Livy, at the time and Penn had always assumed that Leo's motive for doing this was to split Livy and Penn up. Her father having grander plans for her than to marry a local doctor's son.

When the murder, in 1968, of a local black factory worker, Del Payton, is also rumoured to be connected to Leo Marston, Penn decides, with the help of Caitlin Masters, that it's time to bring him down. But how to do this? Things are further complicated when Livy, newly separated from her husband, arrives in Natchez. What is she doing there?

It's a long, long road Penn has embarked upon. It's going to bring tragedy and death and will involve crooked dealings in the highest echelons of political society and the FBI. More than once Penn is going to regret ever becoming involved but he promised the family of Del Payton that he will find out what happened to him and, whatever happens, is determined to keep that promise.

This was a book that was amazingly good on 'setting'. I did wonder, before I started, exactly how 'southern' it would feel. Answer: 'very'. The town of Natchez and the state of Mississippi really came alive and the historical detail was fascinating. I found out a lot about the treatment of the black population in Mississippi in the 1960s and it was interesting the way the author brought in various politicians such as J. Edgar Hoover, and there were mentions of Bobby Kennedy and Martin Luther King of course. All excellent.

But... I was at least 200 pages into this book before I really felt that I had to finish it. Before then, if I'm honest, I found it rather rambling and was getting a bit tired of the author indulging in a bit of male fantasy writing. Ie: two stunningly gorgeous, 'perfect' women who of course found the narrator irresistible, descriptions of one of them in a see-through blouse and so on and so on. I do realise that as a 60+ female reader I'm not the target audience for this book, it's probably aimed at other men and that's maybe what they like to read. But it just makes me sigh that so many male authors just can't seem to bring themselves to write about women as they really are rather than invent these perfect fantasy women. Oddly, the only women in it who felt, to me, like real people were two black characters, Ruby, the maid, and Althea Payton, the murdered man's wife. Penn's father was a very strong character but his mother? I had hardly any sense of her at all. She felt like a shadowy presence in the background to be honest.

It's such a shame because this book has the sort of cracking storyline that would hold up without all that sexual fantasy stupidity. The plot was certainly the reason I kept reading. I'm not really a political/legal thriller reader... not my thing at all normally... but the story had so many twists and turns and so much going on that for me it eventually turned into a real pageturner. I couldn't stop reading and got through the last 400 or so pages in a couple of days. Not until towards the end did I have much of a clue what was really going on. Until then it was just a huge rollercoaster ride, including a night-time river escape that was about as exciting as anything I've read. Hugely entertaining.

Now of course I can't decide whether I want to read more in this series. I'm not sure I want more of the sexual fantasy writing but having read the synopsis for the next book, Turning Angel, it does sound rather good. I'll think seriously on it and perhaps see if my local library actually has the book. (I've now checked and they do so I'll wait for it to come back in and borrow it.)

The Quiet Game is my first book for the The Southern Lit challenge which is being hosted by The Introverted Reader.



When I first started to read your review I thought 'wow, I shall go and download a sample.

Then I got to the bit about it being 200 pages before you really wanted to finish it and all the 'perfect' woman stuff and decided I doubt I'll bother.

I shall look forward to hearing what you think about the second one in the series.
It's so hard to know whether someone else will like a book but if I had to judge I would probably say that 'no' this is probably not for you. The perfect women thing is quite eye rolling tbh, but because it was recced to me by someone whose opinion I respect on my other blog, I ploughed on and *eventually* (*G*) I was reasonably happy that I had. But I did find 600 pages quite a committment, tbh. I've now given it to P to read and will be very interested to hear what he thinks. ;-)
I know it is. It's one reason I tend not to rec books, because it is so hard.

I really do think that would put me off - mind you the length also puts me off somewhat *g*

Oh, right. It will be interesting to learn what he thinks of it.
It does sound interesting... but the implausible sexual fantasy stuff would bother me too. It reminds me a bit of Stuart Kaminsky's "Toby Peters" detective series. He could certainly write a great private detective/period mystery, but his main character was a bit of a jerk, and my memory is of at least one "babe" in each story seducing him. Of course, in the story that I recall best, it was because she had an ulterior motive, and it was a page turner right from the beginning.

It would have been a great role for John Garfield, back in the day, though...
I have a feeling it would bother you. To be honest I think it would bother any older 'thinking' woman. 'Exactly' with the main character being a bit of a jerk. Penn Cage was not too bad really but really stupid around beautiful women. I wanted to give him a damn good shake. On the other hand, perhaps being stupid around pretty women is what a lot of men *are*. LOL!

I do have to say, when all is said and done about this book, it made me think hard about the historical stuff. And I'm wondering if a biography about J. Edgar Hoover might be an interesting thing to read. And books that make you want to investigate something further cannot be all bad.